Shoreline Bird Monitoring Program at Cabrillo National Monument: 1990–2025 Initial Report

Anthony Truong, Taro Katayama, Pamela Zuckerman, Lauren L.M. Pandori

Please cite this publication as:

Truong, A., T. Katayama, P. Zuckerman, and L.L.M. Pandori. 2026. Shoreline Bird Monitoring Program at Cabrillo National Monument: 1990–2025 Initial Report. Science Report NPS/SR—2026/526. National Park Service, Fort Collins, Colorado. https://doi.org/10.36967/2321166

Abstract

In an era of biodiversity loss, long-term datasets on bird abundance and biodiversity are critical indicators of ecosystem health. Here, we present observations and data exploration from over thirty years of shoreline bird monitoring at Cabrillo National Monument (CABR). Species were categorized into the following eleven functional groups based on their specific foraging niches and behavioral characteristics: shorebirds, egrets, herons, gulls, waterfowl, terns, cormorants, pelicans, osprey, kingfisher, and landbirds. Park staff and volunteers have been collecting data on birds in the intertidal zone as well as intertidal visitor information data since 1990 over 50 one-hour visual counts per year (1990–2025). During each count, one to three volunteers walk 60 minutes one way along 1.5 km of shoreline from the most visited to the least visited intertidal area of the park, counting the number of birds with their feet on the ground and the number of visitors. Exploratory data visualization indicates that gulls, as the most abundant species, account for the bulk of observed population changes; furthermore, bird abundance is negatively correlated with the number of visitors to the area. By leveraging decades of volunteer observations, this initiative offers a comprehensive, big-picture view of the stressors affecting shoreline birds, allowing managers to evaluate the impacts of high-volume visitation in an urban park.

A brown pelican spreads its wings, gliding over the ocean. The foreground shows a small one-foot wave breaking. The middle and background show rippling waters.
Brown Pelican landing in the coastal waters off Cabrillo National Monument.

NPS / Pauline Geisler

Acknowledgments

Funding and data management for this project were provided by the Cabrillo National Monument Resources Management & Science division (CABR). Long-term monitoring programs are only made possible through the dedication and meticulous work of program staff and volunteers. We are especially grateful to the Volunteers-in-Parks team, led by Pam Zuckerman, for their diligent collection of visitation data. We also extend our sincere thanks to Katy Delaney for her invaluable expertise and knowledge regarding shoreline birds. We thank Stacey Ostermann-Kelm and Linh Anh Cat for their thoughtful reviews and editorial assistance. Jolie Gareis provided excellent editorial and formatting support.

Introduction

Located at the southern tip of the Point Loma peninsula in San Diego, California, Cabrillo National Monument (CABR) provides critical habitat for avian populations within a landscape of increasing development and urbanization. Fifty-six species of birds are regularly observed foraging and roosting within the rocky intertidal zone of CABR, making these shoreline communities a primary focus of the park’s natural resource management. The park’s coastline is protected as part of the Cabrillo State Marine Reserve, a Marine Protected Area (MPA) containing what is widely considered the best-conserved rocky intertidal shoreline in mainland Southern California. Since three sides of the park are surrounded by water and the fourth abuts a naval installation, the monument functions as an “urban island” where shoreline birds can find refuge and high-quality foraging grounds.

To support effective natural resource management and identify broad population shifts, the avian community at CABR is classified into eleven functional groups based on shared ecological niches and habitat use. Categorizing species into recognizable guilds such as gulls, pelicans, and shorebirds simplifies the identification of drastic or catastrophic trends for non-expert stakeholders. Throughout this report, these groups are collectively referred to as “shoreline birds,” providing a streamlined framework for monitoring the overall health of the coastal ecosystem.

Shoreline bird communities in Southern California are subject to natural and anthropogenic stressors that affect their composition and function. On a climatic scale, accelerated temperature increases (Hobday and Pecl 2014; IPCC 2022), ocean warming (Hobday and Pecl 2014), and decreases in ocean pH (Caldeira and Wickett 2003, 2005; IPCC 2022) are affecting community composition and ecosystem function in marine habitats (Harley et al. 2006; IPCC 2022). This is of particular concern to shoreline birds, which are vulnerable to both naturally occurring (e.g., coastal erosion, boulder movement, storms) and anthropogenic (e.g., visitation, collection, land-use changes) disturbance (Sutherland et al. 2012). These disturbances can impact bird communities by altering survival rates (Stenzel et al. 2023; Warnock et al. 2021), migration patterns (Barton and Sandercock 2018), and availability of food and breeding grounds (Galbraith et al. 2014; Kwon et al. 2019). Impacted shoreline bird populations may undergo range shifts, alter migratory timing, and face declines or even extinction at a local or global scale (Galbraith et al. 2014; Smith et al. 2023). Due to their sensitivity and marked response to these stressors, shoreline birds are effective indicator species for atmospheric and oceanic change (Ogden et al. 2014).

Moreover, shoreline bird community composition can alter the structure and functioning of the broader ecosystems they inhabit (Benkwitt et al. 2022; Booty et al. 2020; Green and Elmberg 2014). As a result, managers must consider 1) whether actions should be taken to mitigate stressors on shoreline bird communities, 2) which mitigation options are available, and 3) how those mitigations may affect other parts of the ecosystem, when making management decisions on natural resource management or visitor use.

In addition to abiotic stressors, shoreline bird communities at CABR are subject to intense visitation pressure. Visitation to the coastal area of the park has increased from 220,000 visitors in 2011 to 380,000 visitors in 2020 (Pandori and Cat 2022; Phillips et al. 2013). While increased visitation to public lands can bring additional funding and community support, it can also have deleterious effects on shoreline birds, even within MPAs. Visitor activities such as noise, trampling, or even visual presence can negatively affect bird fitness, habitat quality, breeding, nesting, and prey abundance (Beauchamp and Gowing 1982; Bötsch et al. 2018; Murchison et al. 2016). The rocky intertidal monitoring program at CABR was planned with visitation stress in mind. Site selection in the 1990s was designed to capture a gradient of visitation across the rocky intertidal zone.

The Shoreline Bird Monitoring arm of the Cabrillo Rocky Intertidal Monitoring Program began in February 1991 with the goal of detecting changes in shoreline bird communities and visitation patterns over time (Becker 2006; Engle and Davis 1996). Despite the potential analytical value of a long-term dataset, no report has been published on the Shoreline Bird Monitoring program at CABR. This report contains the first management summary and visualization of data collected between 1990 and 2025. It sets a precedent for periodic examination of these data over time with the goal of informing management practices, including delivering new informational programs on shoreline birds, enhancing safety communications to decrease wildlife/human conflict, and helping protect sensitive park resources for future generations.

Methods

Study Area

The west side of the park contains 1.5 km of rocky intertidal habitat comprised of gently sloping sandstone benches with metavolcanic boulders scattered at the base of sandstone cliffs. While the intertidal zone at CABR is similar in taxonomic makeup, geological history, currents and wave exposure, the shoreline differs in habitat type (some areas are dominated by benches and others by boulder fields) and encompasses a steep visitation gradient.

The intertidal area is subdivided into three management zones (I, II, and III; Figure 1; Appendix 1), which represent a gradient in human visitation (Engle and Davis 2000). There is a single public access point in the northern area of the CABR rocky intertidal zone. Zone I is in the intertidal area immediately surrounding the entrance to the public access point and receives the most visitation of the management zones. Access to Zone II requires visitors to amble through a boulder field, so it receives fewer visitors than Zone I. Very few visitors make the ~1 km trek southward to the end of Point Loma peninsula, so this area became Zone III. Although Zone III was open to the public when monitoring began in 1991, it was closed to the public in November 1996 and has remained closed since that date. Zone III is accessed by researchers and occasionally by members of the U.S. Coast Guard, which are landowners directly adjacent to Zone III. Surveyors count birds in three areas of Zone III containing flat rocky benches, boulders, and rocky outcrop habitat. The management zones also vary in physical characteristics: Zone I has boulders and a compact vertical gradient, while Zones II and III have larger extents of flat rock benches (Appendix 1). The zones also differ in area: Zone I occupies 3.44 acres, Zone II occupies 4.08 acres, and Zone III occupies 9.45 acres.

Figure 1. Two-panel map figure. Left panel: a regional map of the San Diego area showing the Pacific Ocean and San Diego Bay, with a small black rectangle marking the study area on the Point Loma peninsula near its western tip, and latitude/longitude gridlines (32°36′0″N to 32°48′0″N) plus a scale bar (0–10 km) and north arrow. Right panel: a zoomed-in map of that boxed study area, subdivided into three color-coded intertidal survey zones arranged north to south along the shoreline—Zone I (blue, northernmost), Zone II (green, middle), and Zone III (orange, southernmost, largest area)—bordered by the Pacific Ocean to the west and San Diego Bay to the east, with a scale bar (0–0.6 km).
Figure 1. Map of the intertidal area of Cabrillo National Monument in San Diego, CA. The three management zones of the intertidal area represent different levels of human visitation: Zone I is high use, Zone II is low use, and Zone III is almost no use and has been closed to the public since November 1996.

NPS

Shoreline Bird and Visitor Counts

Park staff and dedicated volunteers have been collecting shoreline bird and intertidal zone visitation data since 1991. Sampling occurs during daytime hours and where low tides are 0.0 feet or below relative to mean lower low water. Each year (1991–2025), approximately 50 one-hour sampling events occurred between fall and spring (usually October–May). During sampling, one to three staff or Volunteers-in-Parks (VIPs) walk 60 minutes one way across the shoreline from the most (Zone 1) to least-visited (Zone III) intertidal area of the park, counting shoreline birds and visitors. There were 15 minutes of sampling allotted per zone, with 15 minutes of travel time given between zones.

Each survey began 30 minutes prior to the predicted low tide time. Surveyors began on the bluffs above Zone I, entered the tidepools at the single tidepool entrance in Zone I, and walked south in the intertidal zone, along the cliffs. As they traversed each zone, they visually scanned the intertidal zone using binoculars for shoreline birds and visitors. Starting in 2006, the total visitor count includes visitors in the water (surfers). Before 2006, they were not counted. Only birds which had their legs touching the ground (this includes rocks, sand, turf, etc.) were counted. Birds in flight were excluded from the census to minimize double-counting and maintain high observer consistency across sites. Furthermore, individuals on cliffs or on the water were omitted, as the study specifically targeted birds utilizing the intertidal habitat. Surveyors recorded the number and species of shoreline birds to the lowest taxonomic level possible.

To assess the avian community at CABR, species were categorized into eleven functional groups based on their specific foraging niches and behavioral characteristics (Table 1). These groupings prioritize functional roles over broad taxonomic classification, allowing managers to track how specific guilds respond to environmental and anthropogenic stressors. The eleven groupings are defined as follows:

  • Shorebirds: Species primarily associated with the physical rocky or sandy substrate, including plovers, oystercatchers, and sandpipers.
  • Egrets: Long-legged waders that utilize shallow tide pools for ambush hunting.
  • Herons: Larger waders that stalk or wait for prey in sheltered coastal pockets.
  • Gulls: Opportunistic generalists that scavenge and forage across both marine and terrestrial zones.
  • Waterfowl: Aquatic species including mergansers, mallards, and grebes that utilize the nearshore zone.
  • Terns: Highly specialized aerial foragers that plunge-dive for small fish in the surf.
  • Cormorants: Pursuit-diving birds that hunt underwater in the nearshore water column.
  • Pelicans: Large-bodied plunge-divers that rely on deeper waters adjacent to the intertidal shelf.
  • Kingfisher: Specialist hunters that utilize coastal perches to dive for prey.
  • Osprey: A specialized raptor hunting nearshore fish.
  • Landbirds: Terrestrial species, including ravens, phoebes, and sparrows, that utilize the high-tide wrack line or cliffs for foraging and roosting.

Table 1. All the shoreline bird species sampled at Cabrillo National Monument from 1991 to 2025, including their assigned functional group, common name, and scientific name.
Functional Group Common Name Scientific Name
Shorebirds Black-bellied Plover Pluvialis squatarola
Shorebirds Black Oystercatcher Haematopus bachmani
Shorebirds American Oystercatcher Haematopus palliatus
Shorebirds Black Turnstone Arenaria melanocephala
Shorebirds Ruddy Turnstone Arenaria interpres
Shorebirds Wandering Tattler Tringa incana
Shorebirds Willet Tringa semipalmata
Shorebirds Whimbrel Numenius phaeopus
Shorebirds Marbled Godwit Limosa fedoa
Shorebirds Sanderling Calidris alba
Shorebirds Least Sandpiper Calidris minutilla
Shorebirds Western Sandpiper Calidris mauri
Shorebirds Spotted Sandpiper Actitis macularius
Shorebirds Surfbird Calidris virgata
Egrets Great Egret Ardea alba
Egrets Snowy Egret Egretta thula
Herons Great Blue Heron Ardea herodias
Herons Green Heron Butorides virescens
Gulls Heermann’s Gull Larus heermanni
Gulls Western Gull Larus occidentalis
Gulls California Gull Larus californicus
Gulls Herring Gull Larus argentatus
Gulls Ring-billed Gull Larus delawarensis
Gulls Short-billed Gull Larus brachyrhynchus
Gulls Bonaparte’s Gull Chroicocephalus philadelphia
Waterfowl Common Merganser Mergus merganser
Waterfowl Red-breasted Merganser Mergus serrator
Waterfowl Mallard Anas platyrhynchos
Waterfowl Western Grebe Aechmophorus occidentalis
Terns Elegant Tern Thalasseus elegans
Terns Royal Tern Thalasseus maximus
Terns Forster’s Tern Sterna forsteri
Cormorants Double-crested Cormorant Nannopterum auritum
Cormorants Pelagic Cormorant Urile pelagicus
Pelicans Brown Pelican Pelecanus occidentalis
Kingfisher Belted Kingfisher Megaceryle alcyon
Osprey Osprey Pandion haliaetus
Landbirds Black Phoebe Sayornis nigricans
Landbirds Say’s Phoebe Sayornis saya
Landbirds Common Raven Corvus corax
Landbirds Northern Mockingbird Mimus polyglottos
Landbirds Song Sparrow Melospiza melodia
Landbirds Savannah Sparrow Passerculus sandwichensis
Landbirds White-crowned Sparrow Zonotrichia leucophrys
Landbirds Yellow-rumped Warbler Setophaga coronata
Landbirds California Towhee Melozone crissalis
Landbirds European Starling Sturnus vulgaris
Landbirds Rock Dove (Pigeon) Columba livia

To account for weather conditions, environmental factors were measured immediately following each survey. A Kestrel hand-held weather gauge was used to record air temperature, average wind speed, and maximum wind speed over a 60-second period. Wind direction was measured with a handheld compass during the same 60-second interval. Wave height (in feet) and cloud cover percentage were estimated by the surveyors.

Prior to 2007, staffing levels permitted conducting as many bird surveys as possible each year. After 2007, fewer surveys were conducted annually (Appendix 2).

Data Entry

All data were recorded on paper datasheets. Year, zone, taxa, and count of each taxa were entered into separate columns of the datasheet. At the end of the sampling year, datasheets were entered into an Access database by park staff.

Quality Assurance and Quality Control

Data were initially extracted from the Access database and underwent a comprehensive quality assurance process. Each survey record starting in 2011 onward was cross-referenced against physical datasheets to verify accuracy and completeness. Missing survey entries or discrepancies in the data were corrected using a custom R Shiny dashboard interface. We used R to merge the corrected R Shiny entries into the primary dataset, prioritizing the Shiny records to ensure the most recently verified data took precedence.

Additional quality control measures included checking for outliers in species counts and survey dates, verifying taxonomic consistency across years, and flagging incomplete survey records for review.

Limitations

Physical datasheets were only available from 2011 onward; therefore, data from 1990 to 2010 could not be subjected to the same quality assurance procedures and should be interpreted with this limitation in mind. The extent of missing datasheets from the 2011–2025 period could not be fully quantified, potentially affecting the completeness of the dataset. Note that there were only four surveys conducted in 2015, but they were included in our analysis.

Data Processing

Data processing, analysis, and visualization were performed using R. Data analysis can be found at: https://github.com/KatayamaTaro/Shorebird/tree/main.

Using the tidyverse suite in R, species were assigned to functional groups (e.g., gulls, shorebirds, pelicans, waterfowl, etc.) based on their taxonomy and habitat use (Table 1). Shoreline bird and visitor trends were visualized by plotting observation counts across both time and zone. To improve comparisons, we standardized the data in two ways: 1) due to uneven sampling among years, we averaged the number of observations by the number of surveys for each year, and 2) two distinct areas were marked as “Boulders” and “Rocky Outcrop” on the datasheets, but because both areas occur within the geographic boundary of Zone III, data from these areas were grouped under Zone III. Observations were then grouped by functional group, year, and zone to calculate an annual abundance metric, defined as the sum of the mean observations per survey. Finally, functional groups were organized as factors to ensure consistent visualization and analysis across all subsequent figures.

The data visualization reported here focuses on the functional groupings of birds, but data pertaining to all other monitored bird species is available upon request by email to . Data will be released on the NPS DataStore here: https://irma.nps.gov/DataStore/Reference/Profile/2315158.

Statistical Tests

To assess temporal changes in visitor and shoreline bird populations, we conducted trend analyses using simple linear regression. For each combination of data type (people or shoreline birds) and geographic zone (Zones I, II, and III), a linear model was fitted with the total annual count as the dependent variable and the year as the independent predictor. The strength and direction of the trends were determined by the regression slope, while the statistical significance was evaluated using a t-test on the slope coefficient with an alpha level of 0.05. Additionally, the coefficient of determination (R2) was calculated for each model to quantify the proportion of variance in population totals explained by the passage of time. Statistical test results are provided in Appendix 3.

Results and Discussion

Human visitation, on average, increased across the monitoring period (1990–2025, Figure 2A). This increase was primarily driven by visitation to Zone I, which experienced 77% of the total visitation across all years. Visitation also increased in Zone II (19% of visitation), while visitation to Zone III (4% of visitation) decreased. Across the three management zones, Zone I and Zone II showed a significant positive increase, while Zone III showed a significant negative decrease in visitation (Figure 2A; Appendix 3).

Figure 2. Two-panel line graph showing “Mean Observations per Survey” from 1990 to 2025 across three geographical zones: Zone I in purple, Zone II in pink, and Zone III in yellow. Each panel includes data points connected by thin lines and a solid trend line with a grey shaded confidence interval. Panel A displays the human count for each zone. Zone I shows the highest frequency, with a steady upward trend from roughly 40 observations in 1990 to 80 in 2025. Zone II remains relatively flat and lower, averaging around 15 observations. Zone III shows the lowest activity, trending slightly downward toward zero over the 35-year period. Panel B displays bird observations. Zone III dominates this panel with a significant, though highly volatile, upward trend, starting near 10 in 1990 and peaking at over 150 in 2025. Zones I and II remain consistently low, hovering near the bottom of the axis (under 10 observations) throughout the entire time series.
Figure 2. Mean observations per survey and standard error for A) visitors and B) shoreline birds from 1991 to 2025 across management Zones I through III at Cabrillo National Monument. Simple linear regression shown. Visitors to Zones I and II increased over time, and the number of shoreline birds increased over time in Zone III. Shoreline birds refer to all birds sampled.

NPS / Anthony Truong

Total number of shoreline birds has also, on average, increased over time (Figure 2B). Shoreline birds noticeably increased in Zone III, which comprised 85% of the total observations and displayed a strong linear relationship with time (Figure 2B, Appendix 3). Zone II, accounting for 9% of observations, showed a slight negative relationship with time, and Zone I, only accounting for 6% of observations, showed no significant relationship with time.

Observation data across the three monitored areas reveals distinct spatial disparities in avian density and composition. Notably, several categories including osprey, waterfowl, and kingfishers were virtually absent across all zones for the duration of the study period, showing negligible mean observations per survey (Figure 3). Zone III supported a significantly higher volume of bird activity compared to Zones I and II. This zone is characterized by heavy concentrations of gulls, pelicans, and terns, particularly from the early 2000s onward, where observation totals frequently reached the highest recorded intensities (Figure 3). While Zones I and II show consistent presence of shorebirds, gulls, and egrets, their populations remain sparse relative to the robust activity levels seen in Zone III. These broad spatial trends provide the foundation for a more granular analysis of individual functional group fluctuations in subsequent figures.

Figure 3. Shows three stacked heatmaps representing annual bird observation totals across Zone I, Zone II, and Zone III from 1990 to 2025. Each heatmap tracks eleven distinct bird categories against a color scale where white and light yellow indicate low activity and dark purple signifies high concentrations reaching up to 100 observations. Across all three zones, the rows for kingfisher, osprey, and waterfowl remain consistently white, reflecting a near-total absence of these species over the 35-year period. While Zones I and II show only sporadic, low-intensity activity primarily concentrated among gulls, egrets, and shorebirds. Zone III exhibits a starkly different profile with dense clusters of dark teal and purple. These high-density values in Zone III are most prominent in the gulls, pelicans, and terns categories, particularly from the early 2000s onward, marking it as the primary hotspot for avian activity in the study area.
Figure 3. Mean number of bird observations per survey each year split by zone. All eleven categories of birds are shown. Kingfishers and osprey were seen rarely and in low numbers, resulting in a mean observation rate of zero in all years and all zones. Data presented in this figure are also available in a spreadsheet of supplemental material that can be downloaded at: https://irma.nps.gov/DataStore/Reference/Profile/2321412.

NPS / taro katayama

In 2000, gulls sharply declined, from averaging 73 observations per survey in 1999 to averaging only eight in 2000; the record low occurred in 2001 with an average of seven observations (Figure 3, Figure 4). Gulls continued to be scarce (relative to previous years) until 2005, when a record high of 115 gulls per survey was reached. We cannot rule out changes in the monitoring methods as a reason for the dramatic decreases in 2000–2004, followed by a record high in 2005. Furthermore, during this period, there was an increase in the number of surveys, ranging from 57 to 70. The high number of surveys may indicate that some sampling days occurred during times of high surf or unideal conditions, resulting in low bird count data skewing the mean lower. Seabird reproductive success in 2005 was broadly reduced across the California Current, coincident with anomalously delayed spring upwelling that led to low primary productivity, reduced krill availability, and widespread breeding failures (e.g., Schwing et al. 2006; Sydeman et al. 2006; Jahncke et al. 2008). However, our data shows widespread increases in multiple functional groups in 2005, which may be more related to methodology than actual shoreline bird numbers. We included historical data that could not be verified with the original datasheets for context, and changes in data collection methodology may have occurred in the early years of this program.

Figure 4. This figure consists of eight line graphs (labeled A through H) showing the mean observations per survey for different bird categories across Zone I (purple), Zone II (red), and Zone III (yellow) from 1990 to 2025. Each panel uses a “free” y-axis to accommodate varying scales of abundance. Across nearly every category—specifically pelicans, terns, cormorants, egrets, and herons— Zone III shows a dominant upward trend and significantly higher volume than the other two zones, particularly after 2005. Shorebirds (Panel A) provide a notable exception, showing a synchronized peak across all zones in the early 2000s followed by a sharp decline toward near-zero observations by 2015. Land birds (Panel H) remain low and sporadic across the timeline. Gulls are the most abundant category, showing an increase over time in Zone III and near zero for Zone I and Zone II.
Figure 4. Mean number of observations per survey for each bird functional group across the three management zones. The y-axis is independent for each group. Of the eleven functional groups, osprey, kingfisher, and waterfowl are excluded.

NPS / Taro Katayama

Gulls drove patterns in shoreline bird abundance (Figure 5). For any given year, gulls contributed more to the total number of bird observations than every other taxa combined, except between 2000 and 2003 (Figure 5). Gulls then continued to be the most common taxa across the remaining years surveyed (Figure 5). The increase in gulls after 2005 was also accompanied by an increase in pelicans, terns, and egrets (Figure 3, Figure 4). Observations for these categories were also primarily made in Zone III. Total shoreline bird observations closely mirror these shifts (Figure 2B), and as a result, changes in overall shoreline bird patterns at CABR across the monitoring period can mostly be attributed to changes in the number of gulls, terns, and pelicans or the manner in which they were recorded (listed in order of number of mean observations) in Zone III.

Figure 5. A stacked bar chart displays the total mean observations per survey for 11 categories of birds from 1990 to 2025. The y-axis ranges from 0 to over 150 mean observations, showing a generally increasing but highly volatile trend over time. Gulls (gold) consistently make up the largest portion of the observations across all years. In the first half of the study, shorebirds (dark purple) represent a significant secondary group, but their presence diminishes after 2005 as pelicans (light blue) and terns (maroon) become much more prominent. Other categories, such as egrets, herons, and cormorants, contribute smaller, fluctuating amounts to the annual totals, while kingfishers, osprey, and waterfowl are barely visible, indicating minimal presence throughout the time series.
Figure 5. Stacked bar chart displaying the mean observations per survey for each taxon of interest from 1991 to 2025.

NPS / anthony truong

Zone III consistently supports the highest mean observations per survey across all groups (Figure 2). Shorebirds exhibited a unique peak in all three zones during the mid-1990s and early 2000s, followed by a substantial decline and stabilization at low levels after 2015 (Figure 4). It is notable that this mostly volunteer operated program was able to document a decrease in shoreline birds during the 2013–2015 massive marine heatwave (“the Blob”). The Blob developed in the northeast Pacific and extended throughout the California Current, producing anomalously warm, nutrient-poor conditions that disrupted marine food webs and led to widespread seabird reproductive failure and mortality (Bond et al. 2015; Leising et al. 2015; Cavole et al. 2016; Piatt et al. 2020).

In contrast, several species showed marked increases in Zone III during the latter half of the study period. Pelicans and cormorants remained largely absent until approximately 2005, after which pelicans showed a volatile but upward trend peaking in 2025, while cormorants stabilized at higher levels through the 2010s and have decreased in number recently. Terns displayed significant periodic fluctuations, with major spikes around 2010 and 2022. Both egrets and herons demonstrated a steady, long-term increase in Zone III, characterized by high inter-annual variability compared to the negligible presence of these species in Zones I and II. Landbirds remained the most sporadic category, showing no clear long-term trend but featuring synchronized occasional spikes across all three zones, most notably in 2005 and 2022.

Some trends in bird abundances may be explained by survey design. In this study, only birds with their feet planted in the habitat were counted. Shoreline birds on the water or flying overhead were not included in counts. Thus, behavioral traits (e.g., foraging mode, habitat type) influence bird abundances. For example, cormorants and osprey are commonly observed in the water and flying overhead, respectively. Abundances of these species are likely under-reported because they do not fit survey criteria.

Overall, we have utilized a previously unexamined 30-plus-year monitoring dataset to detect trends in visitor and shoreline bird patterns across three management zones. Two key findings were revealed by this examination:

  • The increasing number of visitors experienced in Zones I and II appears to be correlated with low counts of most birds while the opposite pattern is observed in Zone III (low number of visitors and high number of birds). Although visitor-related stressors likely drive these patterns, we lack data collected during periods of zero visitation, including during the 2020 COVID pandemic. Therefore, we cannot parse the effect of visitors on shoreline birds from other factors, such as natural differences between the zones. Additional monitoring or experimental efforts designed to pinpoint and mitigate visitor-related stress to shoreline birds would be useful for addressing this gap in knowledge and improving available shoreline bird habitat.
  • Comparing shoreline bird data from Zone III with Zones I and II is extremely valuable for documenting shifts in shoreline birds resulting from non-visitation-related stressors, such as disrupted food webs, storms, highly pathogenic avian influenza, or climate change. This is important because shoreline birds play vital roles in coastal communities as early indicator species, high trophic level predators, and subsidy mediators.

For park managers, being accurately informed and responsive to shoreline bird impacts on coastal communities is a critical component for preserving natural resources. The findings presented in this report are evidence that future effort and funding of long-term monitoring will be invaluable for such endeavors.

Literature Cited

  • Barton, G.G., and B.K. Sandercock. 2018. Long-term changes in the seasonal timing of landbird migration on the Pacific Flyway. The Condor 120(1): 30–46. https://doi.org/10.1650/CONDOR-17-88.1
  • Beauchamp, K.A., and M.M. Gowing. 1982. A quantitative assessment of human trampling effects on a rocky intertidal community. Marine Environmental Research 7(4): 279–293.
  • Becker, B.J. 2006. Cabrillo National Monument Rocky Intertidal Monitoring Program: Updated Protocol June 2006. National Park Service. San Diego, California.
  • Benkwitt, C.E., P. Carr, S.K. Wilson, and N.A.J. Graham. 2022. Seabird diversity and biomass enhance cross-ecosystem nutrient subsidies. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 289(1974): 20220195.
  • Bond, N.A., M.F. Cronin, H. Freeland, and N. Mantua. 2015. Causes and impacts of the 2014 warm anomaly in the NE Pacific. Geophysical Research Letters 42: 3414–3420. https://doi.org/10.1002/2015GL063306
  • Booty, J.M., G.J.C. Underwood, A. Parris, R.G. Davies, and T.J. Tolhurst. 2020. Shorebirds affect ecosystem functioning on an intertidal mudflat. Frontiers in Marine Science 7: 685.
  • Bötsch, Y., Z. Tablado, D. Scherl, M. Kéry, R.F. Graf, and L. Jenni. 2018. Effect of recreational trails on forest birds: human presence matters. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 6: 175.
  • Caldeira, K., and M.E. Wickett. 2003. Anthropogenic carbon and ocean pH. Nature 425: 365. https://doi.org/10.1038/425365a
  • Caldeira, K., and M.E. Wickett. 2005. Ocean model predictions of chemistry changes from carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere and ocean. Journal of Geophysical Research 110: C09S04. https://doi.org/10.1029/2004JC002671
  • Cavole, L.M., et al. 2016. Biological impacts of the 2013–2015 warm-water anomaly in the northeast Pacific: Winners, losers, and the future. Oceanography 29(2): 273–285. https://doi.org/10.5670/oceanog.2016.32
  • Engle, J.M., and G.E. Davis. 1996. Rocky intertidal resources monitoring handbook: Cabrillo National Monument Point Loma, San Diego, California. U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 00-202. Cabrillo Historical Association and Cabrillo National Monument. San Diego, California.
  • Engle, J.M., and G.E. Davis. 2000. Ecological condition and public use of the Cabrillo National Monument intertidal zone, 1990–1995. U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 00-98. Sacramento, California.
  • Galbraith, H., D.W. DesRochers, S. Brown, and J.M. Reed. 2014. Predicting vulnerabilities of North American shorebirds to climate change. PLoS ONE 9(9): e108899.
  • Green, A.J., and J. Elmberg. 2014. Ecosystem services provided by waterbirds. Biological Reviews 89: 105–122. https://doi.org/10.1111/brv.12045
  • Harley, C.D.G., A.R. Hughes, K.M. Hultgren, B.G. Miner, C.J.B. Sorte, C.S. Thornber, L.F. Rodriguez, L. Tomanek, and S.L. Williams. 2006. The impacts of climate change in coastal marine systems. Ecology Letters 9: 228–241. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2005.00871.x
  • Hobday, A., and G. Pecl. 2014. Identification of global marine hotspots: Sentinels for change and vanguards for adaptation action. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 24: 415–438. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-013-9326-6
  • IPCC. 2022. Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [H.-O. Pörtner et al. (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge, UK and New York, New York, USA. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009325844
  • Jahncke, J., et al. 2008. Seabird distribution, abundance, and ecosystem structure in the California Current system. Progress in Oceanography 79: 95–11.
  • Kwon, E., E.L. Weiser, R.B. Lanctot, S.C. Brown, H.R. Gates, H.G. Gilchrist, S.J. Kendall, D.B. Lank, J.R. Liebezeit, et al. 2019. Geographic variation in the intensity of warming and phenological mismatch between Arctic shorebirds and invertebrates. Ecological Monographs 89(4): e01383. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.1383
  • Leising, A.W., et al. 2015. State of the California Current 2014–15: Impacts of the warm-water “Blob”. California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigations Reports 56: 31–68.
  • Murchison, C.R., Y. Zharikov, and E. Nol. 2016. Human activity and habitat characteristics influence shorebird habitat use and behavior at a Vancouver Island migratory stopover site. Environmental Management 58: 386–398.
  • Ogden, J.C., J.D. Baldwin, O.L. Bass, J.A. Browder, M.I. Cook, P.C. Frederick, P.E. Frezza, R.A. Galvez, A.B. Hodgson, et al. 2014. Waterbirds as indicators of ecosystem health in the coastal marine habitats of southern Florida: 1. Selection and justification for a suite of indicator species. Ecological Indicators 44: 148–163. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2014.03.007
  • Pandori, L.L.M., and L.A. Cat. 2022. Coastal area visitation patterns at Cabrillo National Monument: 2011–2020 visitation data summary and analysis. Natural Resource Report NPS/CABR/NRR—2022/2417. National Park Service. Fort Collins, Colorado. https://doi.org/10.36967/2284467
  • Phillips, B., T. Philippi, and B. Pister. 2013. Rocky intertidal visitor count at Cabrillo National Monument: Data summary 2011. Natural Resource Data Series NPS/CABR/NRDS—2013/464. National Park Service. Fort Collins, Colorado.
  • Piatt, J.F., et al. 2020. Extreme mortality and reproductive failure of common murres resulting from the northeast Pacific marine heatwave of 2014–2016. PLoS ONE 15(1): e0226087. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0226087
  • Schwing, F.B., N.A. Bond, S.J. Bograd, T. Mitchell, M.A. Alexander, and N. Mantua. 2006. Delayed coastal upwelling along the U.S. West Coast in 2005: A historical perspective. Geophysical Research Letters 33: L22S01.
  • Smith, P.A., A.C. Smith, B. Andres, C.M. France, B. Harrington, C. Friis, R.I.G. Morrison, J. Paquet, B. Winn, and S. Brown. 2023. Accelerating declines of North America’s shorebirds signal the need for urgent conservation action. Ornithological Applications 125(2): duad003. https://doi.org/10.1093/ornithapp/duad003
  • Stenzel, L.E., B.R. Hudgens, G.W. Page, K.K. Neuman, A.L. Palkovic, J.L. Erbes, C.R. Eyster, B.A. Ramer, and D.E. George. 2023. Climate change consequences for differential adult survival and the mating system of a temperate breeding shorebird. Ecosphere 14(7): e4608. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.4608
  • Sutherland, W.J., J.A. Alves, T. Amano, C.H. Chang, N.C. Davidson, C.M. Finlayson, J.A. Gill, R.E. Gill Jr., P.M. González, et al. 2012. A horizon scanning assessment of current and potential future threats to migratory shorebirds. Ibis 154: 663–679. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1474-919X.2012.01261.x
  • Sydeman, W.J., et al. 2006. Planktivorous auklet (Ptychoramphus aleuticus) responses to the anomaly of 2005 in the California Current. Geophysical Research Letters 33: L22S09.
  • Warnock, N., S. Jennings, J.P. Kelly, T.E. Condeso, and D. Lumpkin. 2021. Declining wintering shorebird populations at a temperate estuary in California: A 30-year perspective. Ornithological Applications 123(1): duaa060. https://doi.org/10.1093/ornithapp/duaa060

Appendix 1: Intertidal Zone Delineation Photos

Figures 6 through 9 show the delineation lines between the different intertidal zones (I, II, and III) at Cabrillo National Monument.

Figure 6. Annotated photograph of a rocky intertidal shoreline at Cabrillo National Monument, looking north along the coast, with waves breaking on tide-pool rocks to the left and layered sandstone cliffs rising on the right. A yellow label “ZI” marks the near foreground as Zone I, with a red horizontal line across the rocks indicating the Zone I boundary. A yellow label reading “North of Z1 boundary / Do not include” sits just above and north of that red line. Further up the coast, a yellow label “Southern edge of large U in cliffs” points to a U-shaped notch in the cliff face used as a landmark. A white arrow in the lower right marks north.
Figure 6. The northern boundary of Zone I.

NPS

Figure 7. Annotated photograph of the rocky intertidal shoreline at Point Loma, looking roughly southeast, with sandstone cliffs and a fenced clifftop facility along the top of the frame, tide pools and scattered rocks in the foreground, and waves visible at lower right. A yellow label reads “Boundary between ZI and ZII is at the drain-pipe and perpendicular to the cliff edge.” A red horizontal line runs across the rock bench at the base of the cliff marking that boundary, with “ZII” labeled above the line and “ZI” labeled below it. A white arrow in the lower right marks north, pointing toward the lower left.
Figure 7. The boundary between Zone I and Zone II.

NPS

Figure 8. Annotated photograph of a rocky intertidal shoreline under an overcast sky, with a dark rocky outcrop and boulder field on the left and scattered rocks in the foreground. A small red “Do Not Enter” sign is visible on the rocks in the middle distance, near a red flag marker. A yellow label reads “‘Area Closed’ sign marks the boundary between Zone II and Zone III”, with a second label noting “Boundary is perpendicular to cliff edge.” A red horizontal line extends across the rocks and into the water marking the boundary, with “ZIII” labeled above the line and “ZII” labeled below it. A white arrow in the lower right marks north, pointing toward the lower left.
Figure 8. The boundary between Zone II and Zone III.

NPS

Figure 9. Annotated photograph of a broad, algae-covered rocky intertidal flat under clear skies, with a layered sandstone cliff and a boulder revetment at the tip of the peninsula on the left, and calm water and distant coastline on the horizon to the right. A yellow label reads “Row of boulders at end of peninsula marks the eastern and southern boundary of ZIII.” A red horizontal line runs along the row of dark boulders near the water’s edge marking that boundary, with “ZIII” labeled in the foreground south of the line. A white arrow in the lower right marks north, pointing toward the lower left.
Figure 9. The outer boundary of Zone III.

NPS

Appendix 2: Survey Efforts 1990–2025

Table 2 describes survey efforts across survey years, including the number of surveys conducted each year and the average number of people and birds observed.

Table 2. Survey efforts 1990–2025.
Year Surveys per Year Average Birds per Survey Average Visitors per Survey
1990 18 N/A 120
1991 52 9 77
1992 50 38 44
1993 85 63 56
1994 99 56 54
1995 65 28 52
1996 49 74 64
1997 40 80 37
1998 49 104 53
1999 50 112 58
2000 57 28 58
2001 55 29 59
2002 55 33 58
2003 69 43 69
2004 70 43 63
2005 47 163 51
2006 46 148 63
2007 50 108 78
2008 51 113 76
2009 52 114 74
2010 45 115 69
2011 50 151 83
2012 54 166 88
2013 39 155 83
2014 18 87 82
2015 4 53 105
2016 22 82 101
2017 18 92 129
2018 23 86 104
2019 16 61 117
2020 22 67 96
2021 31 98 78
2022 27 119 89
2023 19 123 96
2024 23 95 83
2025 15 177 79

Appendix 3: Simple Linear Regression Analysis on Visitation and Shoreline Birds

To evaluate temporal trends in visitor and shoreline bird activity across monitoring zones, linear regressions were run for each zone, with results summarized in Table 3.

Table 3. Linear regression results for people and shoreline bird counts by zone, showing slope, statistical significance (p-value), model fit (R2), and significance status (a = 0.05).
DataType Zone Slope p_value r_squared Significant
People Zone I 1.160662 6.8E-06 0.453354 TRUE
People Zone II 0.198155 0.017716 0.154499 TRUE
People Zone III −0.1514 0.00097 0.277292 TRUE
Shoreline Birds Zone I −0.06999 0.083936 0.087791 FALSE
Shoreline Birds Zone II −0.11763 0.030967 0.133403 TRUE
Shoreline Birds Zone III 2.338711 0.000652 0.300475 TRUE

Author Information

Anthony Truong 1

Taro Katayama 1

Pamela Zuckerman 1

Lauren L.M. Pandori 2 ORCID ID Logo https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8116-8769

1 National Park Service
Cabrillo National Monument
1800 Cabrillo Memorial Dr.
San Diego, CA 92106

2 National Park Service
Mediterranean Coast Network Inventory and Monitoring Program
1800 Cabrillo Memorial Dr.
San Diego, CA 92106

About the National Park Service Science Report Series

The National Park Service Science Report Series disseminates information, analysis, and results of scientific studies and related topics concerning resources and lands managed by the National Park Service. The series supports the advancement of science, informed decisions, and the achievement of the National Park Service mission.

All manuscripts in the series receive the appropriate level of peer review to ensure that the information is scientifically credible and technically accurate.

Views, statements, findings, conclusions, recommendations, and data in this report do not necessarily reflect views and policies of the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior. Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use by the U.S. Government.

The Department of the Interior protects and manages the nation’s natural resources and cultural heritage; provides scientific and other information about those resources; and honors its special responsibilities to American Indians, Alaska Natives, and affiliated Island Communities.

This report is available in digital format from the National Park Service DataStore and the Natural Resource Publications Management website. If you have difficulty accessing information in this publication, particularly if using assistive technology, please email irma@nps.gov.