Results and Discussion
Human visitation, on average, increased across the monitoring period
(1990–2025, Figure 2A). This increase was primarily driven by visitation
to Zone I, which experienced 77% of the total visitation across all
years. Visitation also increased in Zone II (19% of visitation), while
visitation to Zone III (4% of visitation) decreased. Across the three
management zones, Zone I and Zone II showed a significant positive
increase, while Zone III showed a significant negative decrease in
visitation (Figure 2A; Appendix 3).
Figure 2. Mean observations per survey and standard
error for A) visitors and B) shoreline birds from 1991 to 2025 across
management Zones I through III at Cabrillo National Monument. Simple
linear regression shown. Visitors to Zones I and II increased over time,
and the number of shoreline birds increased over time in Zone III.
Shoreline birds refer to all birds sampled.
NPS / Anthony Truong
Total number of shoreline birds has also, on average, increased over
time (Figure 2B). Shoreline birds noticeably increased in Zone III,
which comprised 85% of the total observations and displayed a strong
linear relationship with time (Figure 2B, Appendix 3). Zone II,
accounting for 9% of observations, showed a slight negative relationship
with time, and Zone I, only accounting for 6% of observations, showed no
significant relationship with time.
Observation data across the three monitored areas reveals distinct
spatial disparities in avian density and composition. Notably, several
categories including osprey, waterfowl, and kingfishers were virtually
absent across all zones for the duration of the study period, showing
negligible mean observations per survey (Figure 3). Zone III supported a
significantly higher volume of bird activity compared to Zones I and II.
This zone is characterized by heavy concentrations of gulls, pelicans,
and terns, particularly from the early 2000s onward, where observation
totals frequently reached the highest recorded intensities (Figure 3).
While Zones I and II show consistent presence of shorebirds, gulls, and
egrets, their populations remain sparse relative to the robust activity
levels seen in Zone III. These broad spatial trends provide the
foundation for a more granular analysis of individual functional group
fluctuations in subsequent figures.
Figure 3. Mean number of bird observations per
survey each year split by zone. All eleven categories of birds are
shown. Kingfishers and osprey were seen rarely and in low numbers,
resulting in a mean observation rate of zero in all years and all zones.
Data presented in this figure are also available in a spreadsheet of
supplemental material that can be downloaded at: https://irma.nps.gov/DataStore/Reference/Profile/2321412 .
NPS / taro katayama
In 2000, gulls sharply declined, from averaging 73 observations per
survey in 1999 to averaging only eight in 2000; the record low occurred
in 2001 with an average of seven observations (Figure 3, Figure 4).
Gulls continued to be scarce (relative to previous years) until 2005,
when a record high of 115 gulls per survey was reached. We cannot rule
out changes in the monitoring methods as a reason for the dramatic
decreases in 2000–2004, followed by a record high in 2005. Furthermore,
during this period, there was an increase in the number of surveys,
ranging from 57 to 70. The high number of surveys may indicate that some
sampling days occurred during times of high surf or unideal conditions,
resulting in low bird count data skewing the mean lower. Seabird
reproductive success in 2005 was broadly reduced across the California
Current, coincident with anomalously delayed spring upwelling that led
to low primary productivity, reduced krill availability, and widespread
breeding failures (e.g., Schwing et al. 2006; Sydeman et al. 2006;
Jahncke et al. 2008). However, our data shows widespread increases in
multiple functional groups in 2005, which may be more related to
methodology than actual shoreline bird numbers. We included historical
data that could not be verified with the original datasheets for
context, and changes in data collection methodology may have occurred in
the early years of this program.
Figure 4. Mean number of observations per survey for
each bird functional group across the three management zones. The y-axis
is independent for each group. Of the eleven functional groups, osprey,
kingfisher, and waterfowl are excluded.
NPS / Taro Katayama
Gulls drove patterns in shoreline bird abundance (Figure 5). For any
given year, gulls contributed more to the total number of bird
observations than every other taxa combined, except between 2000 and
2003 (Figure 5). Gulls then continued to be the most common taxa across
the remaining years surveyed (Figure 5). The increase in gulls after
2005 was also accompanied by an increase in pelicans, terns, and egrets
(Figure 3, Figure 4). Observations for these categories were also
primarily made in Zone III. Total shoreline bird observations closely
mirror these shifts (Figure 2B), and as a result, changes in overall
shoreline bird patterns at CABR across the monitoring period can mostly
be attributed to changes in the number of gulls, terns, and pelicans or
the manner in which they were recorded (listed in order of number of
mean observations) in Zone III.
Figure 5. Stacked bar chart displaying the mean
observations per survey for each taxon of interest from 1991 to
2025.
NPS / anthony truong
Zone III consistently supports the highest mean observations per
survey across all groups (Figure 2). Shorebirds exhibited a unique peak
in all three zones during the mid-1990s and early 2000s, followed by a
substantial decline and stabilization at low levels after 2015 (Figure
4). It is notable that this mostly volunteer operated program was able
to document a decrease in shoreline birds during the 2013–2015 massive
marine heatwave (“the Blob”). The Blob developed in the northeast
Pacific and extended throughout the California Current, producing
anomalously warm, nutrient-poor conditions that disrupted marine food
webs and led to widespread seabird reproductive failure and mortality
(Bond et al. 2015; Leising et al. 2015; Cavole et al. 2016; Piatt et al.
2020).
In contrast, several species showed marked increases in Zone III
during the latter half of the study period. Pelicans and cormorants
remained largely absent until approximately 2005, after which pelicans
showed a volatile but upward trend peaking in 2025, while cormorants
stabilized at higher levels through the 2010s and have decreased in
number recently. Terns displayed significant periodic fluctuations, with
major spikes around 2010 and 2022. Both egrets and herons demonstrated a
steady, long-term increase in Zone III, characterized by high
inter-annual variability compared to the negligible presence of these
species in Zones I and II. Landbirds remained the most sporadic
category, showing no clear long-term trend but featuring synchronized
occasional spikes across all three zones, most notably in 2005 and
2022.
Some trends in bird abundances may be explained by survey design. In
this study, only birds with their feet planted in the habitat were
counted. Shoreline birds on the water or flying overhead were not
included in counts. Thus, behavioral traits (e.g., foraging mode,
habitat type) influence bird abundances. For example, cormorants and
osprey are commonly observed in the water and flying overhead,
respectively. Abundances of these species are likely under-reported
because they do not fit survey criteria.
Overall, we have utilized a previously unexamined 30-plus-year
monitoring dataset to detect trends in visitor and shoreline bird
patterns across three management zones. Two key findings were revealed
by this examination:
The increasing number of visitors experienced in Zones I and II
appears to be correlated with low counts of most birds while the
opposite pattern is observed in Zone III (low number of visitors and
high number of birds). Although visitor-related stressors likely drive
these patterns, we lack data collected during periods of zero
visitation, including during the 2020 COVID pandemic. Therefore, we
cannot parse the effect of visitors on shoreline birds from other
factors, such as natural differences between the zones. Additional
monitoring or experimental efforts designed to pinpoint and mitigate
visitor-related stress to shoreline birds would be useful for addressing
this gap in knowledge and improving available shoreline bird
habitat.
Comparing shoreline bird data from Zone III with Zones I and II
is extremely valuable for documenting shifts in shoreline birds
resulting from non-visitation-related stressors, such as disrupted food
webs, storms, highly pathogenic avian influenza, or climate change. This
is important because shoreline birds play vital roles in coastal
communities as early indicator species, high trophic level predators,
and subsidy mediators.
For park managers, being accurately informed and responsive to
shoreline bird impacts on coastal communities is a critical component
for preserving natural resources. The findings presented in this report
are evidence that future effort and funding of long-term monitoring will
be invaluable for such endeavors.